Combinatorial Game Theory
who wins, and by how much
Concept

Zugzwang — where it appears

A position whose owner would rather not move at all, which is what every number is and what no hot game is. Every number is one and no hot position is, which is the practical form of what a number means here.

Named by 10 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A blocked file, and the tempo it holds. Files of a blocked pawn ending: a White pawn below, a Black pawn above, and a gap between them that either side may close one square at a time. Each file carries the value the game recursion gives it. With only single steps available a file is worth a star or nothing, by the parity of the gap, so the whole position is tempo and no material at all — which is what a chess player means by mutual zugzwang.

A pawn ending is a sum

In a blocked pawn ending the material is level, the files never speak to each other, and whoever has to move is the one in trouble. Chess calls that mutual zugzwang; this site calls it a P-position; and the two vocabularies were built four decades and one subject apart to say the same thing.

applied · Chess Push and Shove over every strip up to 6 squares. The same strips under both rules. A cliff lets coins fall off and a wall does not, and the census says what that one clause is worth: both games are entirely made of numbers, they never agree on a value, and the obvious board-reading is right far more often under the wall than under the cliff.

The other way to move a row

Shove has a cliff and Push has a wall, and that is the whole of the difference. Both games make every one of the 728 strips up to six squares a number, so neither ever has anything worth fighting over — and the two rules do not agree on the value of a single position. The obvious board-reading is exact on 446 strips under the wall and on 140 under the cliff, and 486 strips contain a coin its owner cannot move at all.

positions · Push When counting the free squares gets Push right. Every Push strip of at most seven squares, split by whether any line of play can bring two coins of opposite colour together. Where none can, the count of free squares in front of each coin is the value, without exception; where one can, the count is right more often than not.

The reading that survives too much

Counting the empty squares in front of each coin gets a Push position right half the time, and the rung below said the failures were exactly the positions with two coins of opposite colour side by side. Sixty-six of the 1,072 failures have no such pair, the smallest is five squares long, and the condition that does decide it is not about the board at all — it is about every position the board can reach.

positions · Push Which clause of the rules produces which kind of value. Every combination of pawn-file clause in range, sorted by the kind of value it produces. Files where both pawns can advance are all-small and their values are nimbers and infinitesimals. A file where one pawn is stuck behind a friendly piece gives the other side free moves and is worth an integer. A file whose middle square can be held stops the other pawn the moment somebody reaches it, and is worth a switch — a position both players want to move in. The dictionary is read off the evaluation rather than asserted.

What has to break before a pawn is worth a number

Every value the blocked-file model can hold is an infinitesimal, and the reason is one sentence about the move rule rather than anything about pawns. Break that sentence — a pawn stuck behind a friend, a square only one side can hold — and integers, switches and positions worth fighting over arrive at once.

applied · Chess What one king costs a decomposition. Two pawn files and one king a side, solved as a joint position and again as the sum of its files. With the kings unable to move the two answers agree on every configuration, because a king that cannot choose between files is not a shared resource. Give each king a waiting move and the answers come apart, and on some configurations the sum of the parts names the wrong winner rather than merely the wrong value. Independence is a hypothesis about the position and this is the price of assuming it wrongly.

One king, and two files to be in

The whole apparatus needs the files to be independent, and a king is what makes them not. With the kings unable to move the sum of the parts is exact on every configuration; give each king a single waiting move and the sum names the wrong winner on one configuration in six, and on a hundred and twenty-six of two hundred and forty-three with three files.

applied · Chess A fortress, and the counter that gives it a label. A pawn ending where the defender's king shuffles for ever and the attacker needs time. Down the rows, how many moves of preparation the breakthrough needs; across the columns, how many moves the rule allows before declaring a draw. With no breakthrough the position is drawn whatever the rule says, and drawn as a residue the backward induction never reaches. With a breakthrough and no rule the attacker wins despite the cycle. Where the march is longer than the counter allows, the rule turns a won position into a drawn one.

A position with no value, and the rule that gives it one

A fortress is a cycle in the position graph, so the recursion defining a value has nowhere to bottom out and the propagation never reaches it. Chess has a rule for that — count fifty moves and call it drawn — and the rule does not merely tidy the theory up. On eleven cells of the sweep it takes away a win.

applied · Chess What a pass buys, and what it costs. Rows of coins solved with and without a pass. Milnor's mean-value theory needs a non-negative incentive to move, and rows containing a coin nobody wants break that condition — a player forced to take is a player who would rather have passed. Allow a pass and the condition is not merely satisfied but unbreakable, on every row in range. The price is that a player who may pass is never stuck, so the last-move convention has nothing to attach to and the game needs a separate rule to end at all.

What a pass is worth to a theory

The rung below finds fifteen of twenty-seven coin rows where having the move is a disadvantage, and those are exactly the rows Milnor's mean-value theory has to assume away. Allow a pass and the hypothesis stops being a hypothesis — nought violations, on every row in range. What it costs is the convention the rest of this site is built on.

applied · Scoring How many turns are choices. Every position of each game with both sides to move, classified by whether the turn is a choice at all: no move, exactly one move, several moves that all lead to the same verdict, and several that do not. Only the last is a turn at which the alternation is doing any work.

Eleven moves and one decision

A prefix has one quantifier a turn, so a game of eleven moves is eleven alternations. Counted on the boards themselves, a Toads and Frogs strip of eleven moves has twenty-six turns with exactly one move available and one turn anywhere at which the choice changes the answer; a Clobber board has a hundred and fourteen turns and none. Nim, the game everybody calls solved, decides at four turns in five.

complexity · Alternation The same number, from a rule that needs no tie-break. The number computed twice: once as the critical share of a pot under the auction, and once as the probability that Left wins when a fair coin decides who moves at each turn. They agree on every position, and only the second derivation survives being played out.

A coin needs no tie-break

The same recursion has a second derivation: a fair coin decides who moves at each turn, a player whose turn it is with no move has lost, and both play to win. Written from those rules it comes out identical on every position — and it needs no rule for equal bids, because there are no bids. The number is a probability, it belongs to Left rather than Right, and the empty position is the one where the coin decides everything.

limits · Bidding What the flip is worth, and what is at stake. Left's chances if Left moves and if Right moves, with the gap between them beside the position's temperature. The two are answers to the same question computed by different routes, and they do not order the positions the same way.

The coldest position has the biggest swing

How much a flip is worth is the gap between the coin's two branches, and it is a rival to the temperature — both answer how much is at stake. They disagree at once: the empty position has the lowest temperature there is and a swing of one, twice the hottest thing born on day two. On the small pool the two quantities look like a perfect three-way correspondence, and 255 of day three's values break it.

limits · Bidding

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Outcome classExhaustive searchChessInfinitesimalTemperatureDecompositionDyadic rationalNormal playPartizanSpare movesAlternationCanonical form

All concepts