Thermograph — the series · Combinatorial Game Theory

The thermograph of {5 | 1}. Temperature runs up the page and value across it. Each wall is where a player is willing to move once a tax of that much is charged per move; above the temperature at which they meet, neither wants to move and the position is worth its mean value. The height of the meeting point is what is at stake.

Reading a thermograph

A thermograph is two walls rising from a number line, closing in as the tax on moving increases, and meeting where the position stops being worth fighting over. Everything about a position's hotness is in the shape.

part 1 · temperature

The endgame, accounted for

Add up what each region is worth, then add the biggest thing at stake, subtract the next, and so on down. On a board of simple fights the result is exact — and the moment one region has a fight inside it, the account is out by a point.

part 2 · temperature

{2 | 0} + {2 | 0} — where the temperature goes. Three thermographs on one frame: two positions and their sum. The mean of the sum is the sum of the means, every time. The temperature is not: it is bounded by the hottest of the parts and is often far below it, so the number that says how much is at stake in a whole board cannot be got by adding up the parts.

Two hot fights that add to a cold number

The mean of a sum is the sum of the means, every time. The temperature is not — it is bounded by the hottest part and is often far below it. Two positions each worth fighting over can add to a plain number that neither player wants to touch.

part 3 · temperature

The thermograph of {6 | {5 | {4 | 0}}}. Temperature runs up the page and value across it. Each wall is where a player is willing to move once a tax of that much is charged per move; above the temperature at which they meet, neither wants to move and the position is worth its mean value. The height of the meeting point is what is at stake.

A thermograph is built from its options'

The diagram is not measured, it is computed — each wall is an extremum over the options' opposite walls, shifted by the tax. That construction is why a hot follow-up lowers the temperature instead of raising it, and why two fights with the same swing can differ by a factor of two in what is at stake.

part 4 · temperature

The thermograph of {{5 | {3 | 1}} | 0}. Temperature runs up the page and value across it. Each wall is where a player is willing to move once a tax of that much is charged per move; above the temperature at which they meet, neither wants to move and the position is worth its mean value. The height of the meeting point is what is at stake. The marks partway up the walls are the bends: the heights at which the option holding a wall up stops holding it up. Each stands at the temperature of a follow-up. Every one of them is below the temperature of the position itself, which is where the two walls meet.

A thermograph with two bends

A wall bends where the option holding it up stops holding it up, and most drawn thermographs bend once. { {5 | {3 | 1}} | 0} bends twice, at 1 and 3/2, and neither height is its temperature of 7/4 — every bend lies strictly below where the walls meet. Over a census of 17,255 hot positions two levels deep, a second bend in one wall never happened once.

part 5 · temperature

Where a sum's temperature actually lands. Every pair drawn from 45 hot positions, with the temperature of the sum set against the larger of the two temperatures. The bound is never broken and it is almost never used: 864 of the 1035 sums sit exactly at the maximum and 160 are frozen.

How cold a sum of hot games can be

The temperature of a sum is at most the largest temperature in it, and the bound leaves the whole interval below it open. Over 1,035 pairs the sums do not use that interval: 864 sit exactly at the maximum, 160 are frozen outright, and eleven land anywhere in between — every one of them with a component whose wall bends.

part 6 · temperature

Adding two thermographs. Every pair drawn from the 15 values born by day two that are not numbers — 120 sums — with the two walls added pointwise and compared against the true diagram of the sum. The added walls are always an outer bound and the means always add; the whole diagram is right for 92 of the 120, and the 28 it is wrong for are exactly the pairs in which both components are hot.

When two thermographs can be added

The temperature of a sum is not the sum of the temperatures, and the natural repair is to add the whole diagrams instead. Over every pair of hot values born by day two the added walls always bound the true ones and the mast always comes out right — and the whole diagram is right exactly when at most one of the two components is hot, which is precisely the case a reader has no use for.

part 7 · temperature

Where the two diagrams part. Pairs of hot day-two values with the true thermograph of their sum against the one made by adding the components' walls. Every pair parts, and every pair parts at the lower of the two temperatures.

The second bend is the boundary

Adding two thermographs wall by wall gives a diagram that is right at the mast and wrong below it. Over every pair of hot values born by day two, the added walls sit outside the true ones at every height — an outer envelope with the truth somewhere inside — and the two pictures separate at exactly the lower of the two temperatures, on all twenty-eight pairs. Above that height both components are still fights and the addition is exact; one sixteenth below it, every pair has parted.

part 8 · temperature