Combinatorial Game Theory
who wins, and by how much
Series

Numbers — the series

8 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. The simplest number in between. A game whose options are numbers is worth the simplest number strictly between them — and simplest means born earliest, so integers come before halves and halves before quarters. It is not the midpoint, and the difference is the whole content of the rule.

    The simplicity rule

    When both players' options are numbers, the position is worth the simplest number strictly between them. Not the midpoint, not the average, and the difference between "simplest" and "middle" is the entire content of the rule.

    part 1 · values
  2. The numbers, by the day they are born. Zero on the first day, ±1 on the second, and thereafter the simplest number in each remaining gap. Every number reachable in finitely many days is a fraction with a power of two underneath, and every such fraction appears — which is a strange thing for a construction with no arithmetic in it to produce.

    The day a number is born

    Start with a position in which neither player can move, apply one rule, and the numbers appear — but only the fractions with a power of two underneath, and only in a particular order. That order is what "simplest" means.

    part 2 · values
  3. Why nobody moves in the number. A hot position added to a number. Left wins the sum whoever moves — but only by moving in the fight. Spending the move on the number instead hands the position back as a first-player win, with Right to move, which throws the win away. The theorem says this is always so, and here it is happening.

    Numbers avoid numbers

    In a position with a number in it and anything else, the number is never the right move. That is a theorem rather than a heuristic, and it is the closest this subject comes to advice a player can carry into a real game.

    part 3 · values
  4. The days this site can compute, and the ones it cannot. Zero on the first day, ±1 on the second, and thereafter the simplest number in every remaining gap — the construction run by the game recursion, which produces only fractions with a power of two underneath however long it goes on. Below it, three objects the same recursion reaches when the stopping rule is removed, each written with its option set and the exact reason this site's machinery cannot hold it. They are named rather than drawn, which is the honest half of a figure-first collection.

    The numbers came out of the game

    The construction is always taught numbers first and games second, and the discovery ran the other way. Conway arrived at the number system from positions, which is why the definition quantifies over sets of previously built objects rather than over cuts — and why it produces a genuinely different collection at every finite stage.

    part 4 · history
  5. The days this site can compute, and the ones it cannot. Zero on the first day, ±1 on the second, and thereafter the simplest number in every remaining gap — the construction run by the game recursion, which produces only fractions with a power of two underneath however long it goes on. Below it, three objects the same recursion reaches when the stopping rule is removed, each written with its option set and the exact reason this site's machinery cannot hold it. They are named rather than drawn, which is the honest half of a figure-first collection.

    The recursion this site cannot run

    Remove the stopping condition from the construction and it reaches ω, its reciprocal, and one third — none of which this site's evaluator can represent, because it interns a position from a finite list of options. The figure draws what it computes and names what it cannot, which is where the boundary belongs.

    part 5 · values
  6. How old a form is, and how old its value is. Every one of the 256 forms born by day two, placed by the depth it is written at and by the birthday of the value it carries. Nothing sits above the diagonal, because a form cannot be younger than the value in it; the diagonal holds the forms written at exactly their value's birthday, and everything below it is a position written older than it needs to be. The count in each cell was obtained by canonicalising all 256 forms and measuring both depths.

    How old a value is

    A form's depth bounds the birthday of the value inside it, and reducing to canonical form attains the bound — for all 22 values born by day two, with no exception. Twenty-four of the 256 forms are older than what they are worth. The same reduction that makes the bound tight is what puts day three within reach: 98 option sets a side instead of four million, 9,604 forms, 1,474 values, a quarter of a second.

    part 6 · values
  7. How old a sum is. Every unordered pair of the twenty-two values born by day two, with nought dropped because adding it settles nothing — 231 sums. The birthday of each sum was read off its own canonical form and compared with the sum of the two parts' birthdays, which is the bound. The bound holds everywhere and is attained 163 times.

    The birthday of a sum

    Two values born by days m and n have a sum born by day m + n at the latest, which is the bound that stops a board made of many small parts from being unboundedly complicated. Over 231 pairs of day-two values the bound holds every time and is exact 163 times — and every pair it misses by three days or more has a sum that is a number or a nimber, so the slack is not noise but a measure of how much cancelled.

    part 7 · values
  8. Two of three are subadditive. The birthday, the option count and the written length, each tested for subadditivity under the disjunctive sum.

    Two measures bounded, and one not

    A sum is born no later than its parts' birthdays together, and it has no more options than they have between them — a bound nobody had checked, and it is attained. What runs away is the length of the written form: 27 pairs of 231 exceed it, the worst by 29 characters, on a sum with exactly as many options as it was entitled to.

    part 8 · values

All series