Dawson — the series · Combinatorial Game Theory

The Grundy values of ·137, and the exceptions to its period. An octal game's Grundy sequence, with the periodic part in gold and the exceptions in magenta. The exceptions are the point: a sequence described as eventually periodic contains values that disagree with the value one period later and always will, so the period is a statement about a tail and not about the sequence. The rule used to identify an exception is printed, because published lists of them differ by which convention was used.

A chess problem that turned out to be an octal game

Dawson posed it in 1934 as a puzzle about pawns. It is the octal game ·137, its Grundy sequence is eventually periodic with period 34 from heap 52 — and the word doing the work in that sentence is eventually, because five values below the start disagree with their repeats and always will.

part 1 · history

What a certificate costs, in units of the one Guy and Smith wrote. Octal codes with the period of their Grundy sequence, the window a proof of that period needs, and the arithmetic each costs — counted as mex operations and exclusive-ors, which are the two things a person computing by hand actually performs. Everything is priced in units of the certificate for Dawson's chess, so the column reads as multiples of one hand computation rather than as a number of operations. Some codes cost tens of times as much, and some have no certificate at all.

What the arithmetic cost in 1956

The rung below ends by respecting a hand computation without pricing it. Priced in the operations a person actually performs, ·137's certificate is 7,919 of them — and the same sweep says ·47's is sixty-three times that, that a splitting move is what makes the cost quadratic, and that seventeen of sixty-four codes have no certificate at any price.

part 2 · history

The same rules under the convention they were posed in. Dawson's chess under misère play, which is how Dawson posed it. Under normal play every position of the game collapses onto one of a handful of nimbers however large the heaps are allowed to get. Under misère play the positions that behave alike form classes whose number grows with the heap limit, and a heap carries a genus rather than a value. The first wild heap is where the two accounts stop resembling each other, and the classification doubles at exactly the limit that admits it.

The convention Dawson actually used

Dawson published his puzzle as a problem where running out of moves loses you the game, and every compact result about ·137 is about the other convention. Under his own, nine values become a classification that doubles the moment a wild heap enters the range, and a heap stops carrying a number at all.

part 3 · history

One step and four captures. Dawson's pawns on a board three ranks deep and five files wide. A White pawn steps forward on the middle file, and because a capture must be made when one is available, four captures follow: Black takes, White retakes, Black takes, White retakes. Five moves later the three middle files are finished and the two outer files are untouched, which is the octal move taking three from a heap of five and leaving two heaps of one.

The capture that has to be made

Dawson's chess is quoted as the octal game ·137, and the step from a pawn diagram to a row of counters has been taken on trust. Searched as a chess position, the diagram agrees with ·137 on every board from one file to twelve, under both endings, and every exchange it can start is an odd number of moves that lands on one of ·137's options. The whole reduction rests on one rule of the diagram that the octal code never mentions: a capture, when one is available, must be made. Make it optional and the winner changes on two, three, six and seven files.

part 4 · history

A row of files, valued rather than won. Dawson's pawn diagram on a single row of one to 5 files, with the value of the position under each capture rule beside the nimber ·137 gives the corresponding heap. The winners agree throughout; the values agree until five files, where the diagram is worth ∗ and the heap is ∗3.

A wall the pawns cannot cross and the rule can

Two rows of Dawson's diagram separated by a file with no pawn on it: 1,616 moves were examined and not one crosses the gap. With captures optional the rows add on every diagram checked. With captures compulsory they do not, because the compulsion is a rule about the whole board — and the game that is a sum is the one ·137 does not describe.

part 5 · history

One more row, and the correction comes back. Dawson's diagram of three files beside a row of one, then two, then three, each drawn with the difference between the whole board's value and the sum of its rows. The correction is ∗2, then 0, then ∗2: adding a row removes it and adding another restores it.

A difference the rows cannot predict

The diagrams that are not the sum of their rows have been counted and never priced. Priced over 50 diagrams and 63,408,981 positions, the difference takes three values and is a function of nothing a reader can see: seven diagrams whose rows are worth ∗ and ∗ split five to two on it, the third value arrives only at the ninth file, and the one rule that survives is a parity — all twenty-one diagrams of three, five and seven rows add, and every failure carries an even number of rows.

part 6 · history