Combinatorial Game Theory
who wins, and by how much
Generator

Turning Turtles: a row of 12 coins

Turning Turtles: a row of 12 coins
Turning Turtles: a row of 12 coins. A row of coins, some heads and some tails. A move turns some of them over, and the rightmost coin turned must go from heads to tails — which is what makes the game end. The number under each place is what a lone head there is worth, and the row is worth the exclusive or of the places showing heads.

A row of coins, some heads and some tails. A move turns some of them over, and the rightmost coin turned must go from heads to tails — which is what makes the game end. The number under each place is what a lone head there is worth, and the row is worth the exclusive or of the places showing heads.

4 essays call coin-row. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

The positions it draws

9 distinct positions, harvested by running this generator again at the options each essay passed it.

PositionWorth OutcomeDrawn in
heads at 1, 2, 3, 4 of 12 0 P A row of coins is already a sum
heads at 1, 2, 3, 4 of 8 0 P The losing positions are a code
heads at 2, 4, 7 of 12 ∗8 N A row of coins is already a sum
heads at 2, 5, 8 of 8 ∗4 N The code names the move
heads at 1, 8 of 14 0 P A row of coins is already a sum
heads at 6, 9, 12 of 14 ∗7 N A row of coins is already a sum
heads at 3, 5, 6 of 12 0 P A row of coins is already a sum
heads at 3, 5, 8 of 12 ∗14 N The tartan theorem · A row of coins is already a sum
heads at 8 of 12 ∗8 N A row of coins is already a sum

Where it is called

Changing this generator changes every one of these figures.

Turning Turtles: a row of 12 coins. A row of coins, some heads and some tails. A move turns some of them over, and the rightmost coin turned must go from heads to tails — which is what makes the game end. The number under each place is what a lone head there is worth, and the row is worth the exclusive or of the places showing heads. Impartial games

A row of coins is already a sum

Everywhere else on this site a sum is several positions side by side. In a coin-turning game it is one row — each coin showing heads is a game in its own right, and the row is worth the exclusive or of them. The decomposition is inside a single picture.

 A grid of coins, and a multiplication table. The Grundy values of a two-dimensional coin-turning game, computed from its own move rules by a mex at every cell. Down the left and across the top are the one-coin values of the two one-dimensional games it is built from. Every cell is the nimber product of its two edge values — the multiplication defined for the nimber field on algebraic grounds — and beside the grid are the three combining rules a reader would try first, each killed on a named cell. Impartial games

The tartan theorem

The nimbers are a field, with a multiplication defined by a mex-style rule that looks like an algebraist's amusement. Lay two coin-turning games on a grid and the Grundy value of each square is the nimber product of its two coordinates — which is the point at which the multiplication stops being a curiosity and starts computing answers.

 Mock Turtles on 8 coins: every lost position. The rows a player to move has already lost, drawn in full. A filled disc is a coin showing heads. The set is closed under turning over every coin two of its members disagree about, which is what makes it a linear code, and the count of heads in the sparsest of them is the fewest coin turns that separate two lost positions. Impartial games

The losing positions are a code

Turn over one, two or three coins, and the rows a player has already lost turn out to be closed under adding two of them together. That makes them a linear code — and on eight coins it is the extended Hamming code exactly, sixteen words with a weight enumerator of 1 + 14x⁴ + x⁸, produced by a move rule that knows nothing about codes.

 Mock Turtles on 8 coins: finding the move is decoding. Every row of the game, sorted by what it takes to win from it. The lost rows are the codewords; a won row is a codeword with errors, and the winning move is the error pattern that turns them off. The distance column is a fact about the code and the coins column is a fact about the rules, and the two do not quite agree. Impartial games

The code names the move

If the lost rows of a coin-turning game are a linear code, then a won row is a codeword with errors in it and the winning move is whatever turns the errors off. Over all 256 rows of Mock Turtles on eight coins: 16 codewords, 240 won rows, none more than two coins from a lost one — and 64 of them whose cheapest winning move has to turn three coins anyway.

The whole library · The position index · The figures that play back