Combinatorial Game Theory
who wins, and by how much
The collection

Every essay — page 18

One idea per essay, ordered so that the earlier ones set up the later ones — but nothing here depends on being read in sequence.

Particular games

Hackenbush, Nim, Domineering, Toads and Frogs — the specific games the general theory was built to explain.

Every empty NoGo board a build can solve. The empty boards, with the value the recursion returns and the outcome that follows from it. The one-row boards run 0, star, switch and repeat, which is a pattern with no reason behind it that survives past six squares.

Every group must keep breathing

NoGo is Go with no captures at all: a stone may be placed only if, afterwards, every group on the board still has a liberty. That makes a move's legality a fact about the whole board rather than about the squares it occupies — and a board therefore almost never breaks into independent parts. Of 117 boards here whose empty points fall into two regions, 24 are the sum of their regions and 93 are not.

6 figures · Nogo Every Domineering shape up to four squares. The pieces a partly played board falls into, each with the value the recursion gives it. Left plays vertically and Right horizontally, so a tall shape is worth something positive and a wide one something negative, and the quarter turn is not a symmetry of the game.

A board that is a sum of its regions

A table of rectangles is a table about the openings. A partly played Domineering board is not a rectangle, and evaluating one means splitting it into pieces no domino can straddle, looking each piece up and adding. The catalogue of 104 shapes does it correctly on every one of the 3,227 positions of a 3×4 board it covers — and among the shapes are two worth an up and a down, which no rectangle ever is.

6 figures · Domineering Every strip, without the hop. Toads and Frogs with the jump deleted, over every strip up to eight squares. The fourth column is the argument: whenever the value is a number it is a whole number, without exception, so the fractions the ordinary game produces are made by the hop and by nothing else.

The strip where every number is a whole one

Delete the hop from Toads and Frogs and the halves, quarters and ups vanish completely: over 9,801 strips, every value that is a number is an integer, without a single exception. The guess that the hopless game therefore has a formula reading the gaps is half right and exactly wrong — 1,460 strips of eight squares are switches, and three strips with the same counts of toads, frogs and empty squares are worth 1, {2 | 1} and 2.

6 figures · Toads and Frogs What an approximation is worth. Every pair of Clobber rows up to six squares, judged twice: by their up-brackets and by the comparison itself. The bracket is never wrong where it speaks, and most of what it declines to answer has no answer.

When the bracket decides

A Clobber row's value is an all-small game nobody can hold in their head, so the practical answer is the up-bracket: a pair of integers between which its atomic weight must lie. As an approximation it is worth exactly what it settles — 1,585 of 7,875 pairs of rows are ordered by it, every one of those orders is right, and of the 6,290 it declines, 4,222 have no answer either.

6 figures · Clobber What the third colour reaches. Every row of Toppling Dominoes up to 7 long, over two colours and over three, with the number of distinct values each set of rows carries. Each value was computed by the recursion; the last column is the count of values three colours reach that two do not, cumulatively.

How long a row a value needs

Add a third colour that either player may topple and a row of seven dominoes reaches 1,047 distinct values where two colours reach 149. That makes the length of the shortest row worth a value into a measure of the value's complexity — one a reader can hold in their hand — and it is not the birthday: 1↑ is born on day three and needs seven dominoes.

7 figures · Toppling dominoes When the regions add. Every board in the independence census — 117 positions whose empty points fall into two or more regions — tested against a stated criterion and against the guess it replaces. The criterion is that no stone group has liberties in two different regions, which makes a move in one region unable to change what is legal in another. It holds on 9 boards and the regions add on every one of them.

When the regions add

The rung below described the NoGo boards whose regions add as the ones with symmetric walls, and said the description was a guess made from six examples. It is wrong: fourteen symmetric boards do not add and sixteen that add are not symmetric. What replaces it is a criterion about liberties — sound on all 117 boards, provable in a line, and complete on only nine of the twenty-four.

8 figures · Nogo A sequence with a rule and no period. The values of the subtraction game with Left taking 1 or 2 and Right taking 1 or 3, from heap 5 up. Each is the game whose only Left option is nought and whose only Right option is the value three heaps below — checked at every heap rather than asserted, and the two heaps where it fails are the two below the seeds.

A sequence with a rule and no period

The values of the subtraction game where Left takes one or two and Right takes one or three never repeat — thirty-one heaps, thirty-one different values. They are nonetheless completely described: three seeds and the rule v(k + 3) = {0 | v(k)} generate every one of them, which is what a pattern without a period looks like.

8 figures · Partizan subtraction What a Domineering region is worth, by size. Every connected shape of at most six free squares, sorted by whether its value is a number, an infinitesimal distance from a number, or hot. Hot shapes do not appear at all until four squares, and the hottest shape of six is the two-by-three rectangle.

Which shapes are worth fighting over

Forty-four of the 104 Domineering regions of at most six squares are worth numbers and the rest are not, and the rung below said no visible property of a shape predicts which. Half of that is wrong: a region only one orientation fits in is a whole number, on all eleven of them, for a reason a reader can supply in a sentence. The other half stands, and thirty-three shapes are what makes it stand.

7 figures · Domineering When counting the free squares gets Push right. Every Push strip of at most seven squares, split by whether any line of play can bring two coins of opposite colour together. Where none can, the count of free squares in front of each coin is the value, without exception; where one can, the count is right more often than not.

The reading that survives too much

Counting the empty squares in front of each coin gets a Push position right half the time, and the rung below said the failures were exactly the positions with two coins of opposite colour side by side. Sixty-six of the 1,072 failures have no such pair, the smallest is five squares long, and the condition that does decide it is not about the board at all — it is about every position the board can reach.

7 figures · Push How much of End-Nim is a Nim heap. Rows of End-Nim by length, with the share worth a nimber beside the share that are palindromes and the number of distinct values. The impartial share falls from all of the one-heap rows to a fifteenth of the six-heap rows, while the values multiply.

Where the nimbers run out

A single End-Nim heap is a Nim heap and every palindromic row is worth a nimber, so the impartial theory looks as though it might get a long way into a partizan game. It gets one row in thirteen. Five nimbers occur in five and a half thousand rows, the palindromes account for two fifths of them, and the rows worth something else run to 2,693 distinct values.

8 figures · End-Nim How much a domino count knows about a region. The difference between the two players' largest domino packings, set against the value of the region. On the regions worth numbers the count is the value under half the time; on the rest it lands somewhere between the two stops on 85 per cent of them.

Counting the moves each side has

How many dominoes could each player still place? Subtract, and there is a whole number computable from the drawing with no game theory in it. Over 1,042 regions it is the value on 141 of the 315 worth numbers, lands between the stops on 619 of the other 727, and its failures are two different kinds — one of which was inevitable and one of which is a fact about the game.

6 figures · Domineering Three counts, and two of them are the same number. Rows of End-Nim that read the same backwards, rows equal to their own negative, and rows worth a nimber. The second and third counts are identical over every row in the sweep, so being its own negative is exactly the condition for being worth a nimber in this game.

The rows that are their own mirror

Four hundred and ten End-Nim rows are worth nimbers and 168 of them are palindromes, so a condition covering the other 242 was outstanding. It is that the row is equal to its own negative — and on this game that condition is not merely sufficient but exact, which is more than the group law promises and is a fact about End-Nim rather than about games.

6 figures · End-Nim Thickness is not the variable; the wall's own groups are. The same strips split by whether the wall is all one colour. A wall of one colour is a single group with liberties on both sides and it never separates them, at any thickness. A wall of two colours is two groups breathing in opposite directions and it nearly always does.

How thick a wall has to be

A single stone between two empty stretches of a NoGo board couples them, and the obvious repair is a thicker wall. Over 590 walled strips a thicker wall does help — and splitting the same 590 by the colour of the stones shows that thickness was never the variable. A wall of four one colour couples the sides exactly as one stone does.

6 figures · Nogo What the correction buys. The packing count as a point against the packing count as an interval, on the regions worth numbers. The point is right on 141 of 315; the interval contains the value on 209, at a mean width of about half a move.

The moves a player can be talked out of

The difference of the two players' largest domino packings is the value of a Domineering region on 141 of the 315 worth numbers. The count is optimistic for its owner and pessimistic for the other, and one number cannot be both — so it becomes an interval, from what a player can be reduced to against what the opponent can achieve. The interval contains the value on 209, is a single point on 505 of the 1,042 regions, and never exceeds two moves wide.

6 figures · Domineering Two thousand values and no temperature. Every End-Nim row of up to six heaps, with its temperature. Not one of the 5,460 is hot, every one of them is worth an infinitesimal, and the 361 worth numbers are 361 rows worth nought.

A game with nothing at stake

The rung below explained a coincidence with a claim it did not compute: that End-Nim carries no hot self-negative values. The census says something stronger. Not one of 10,919 rows across three shapes of board is hot, every one of them is worth an infinitesimal, and the 361 rows the earlier census called numbers are 361 rows worth nought. The reason is one line of the rule, and 2,693 distinct values sit underneath it.

6 figures · End-Nim

All ladders · Every object named here · The position index · Figures that play back · Search